- Jenny McCarthy, Scream 3, 1999. More Ghostface murders begin during the shooting of Stab 3… the horror flick inside the horror flick! Ali, Monica and Tara were on director Wes Craven’s short list for one of the new victims: Sarah Darling. But so was Jenny – and she refused a role in the Scream-send-up, Scary Movie, in order to to play the role. She went on top star in Scary Movie 2 in 2001.
- Amy Smart, The Butterfly Effect, 2003. Change of Kayleigh in Hollywood’s “most widely read unproduced script” when Kutcher (of all people!) decided to produce… and star. (Not as bad as it first sounded).
- Jessica Alba, Fantastic Four, 2004. Up for Marvel’s Susan Storm, aka Invisible Woman – alongside Elizabeth Banks, Kate Bosworth, Scarlett Johansson, Rachel McAdams, Denise Richards, Meg Ryan, Julia Stiles, KaDee Strickland, Renee Zellweger. The following year the New Jersey blonde hit big as Niki in Heroes, 2006-2009.
- Ashley Laurence, Deception, 2011. One AL for another… Ali was the immediate choice for Claire Pruitt when Holly Marie Combs decided to spend more time with her family. Ali had to spent her time the TV series, Heroes, 2006-2010. Laurence was the Hellraiser franchise queen, 1987-1999.
Birth year: Death year: Other name: Casting Calls: 4